After planning the baby shower, decorations are set, food is sorted, and then the question comes up: what do you give game winners?
Go too generic and guests forget it straight away. Go too fancy and you spend more than you should on something no one really wants.
That’s why Australian Favors picked three standout gift ideas for baby shower game prizes. For years, our team has helped families choose gifts that people actually use. We’ve tested many options at real showers and gathered honest feedback. These three picks stand out every time.
Quick Comparison: Best Baby Shower Gifts for Games
Product | Best For | Our Rating |
We Can Bearly Wait Bear Lip Balms (30 Pack) | Bear-themed showers, practical prizes | 4.5/5 |
Brown Bear Pacifier Hunt Game Set (51PCS) | Interactive game activity + favour combo | 4.6/5 |
Woodland Baby Is Blooming Seed Packets (50 Pack) | Nature-themed showers, heartfelt keepsakes | 4.4/5 |
Product 1: We Can Bearly Wait Bear Theme Lip Balms (30 Pack)
Charming, practical, and genuinely well-made. These little bear lip balms are the kind of game prize that guests actually take home and use, which is more than we can say for most shower favours.
Pros
Each balm is housed in a small bear-shaped tube. It doesn’t feel cheap. The cap clicks on satisfyingly, and the product itself glides on without any greasy residue.
We’ve handed these out at two separate bear-themed showers now. Both times, guests lit up when they won one. Several reached out afterward to say they’d kept it in their handbag for weeks.
What we appreciate most is the packaging. The “We Can Bearly Wait” label is sweet without being over the top. It fits naturally into a bear nursery theme or a “build a bear” shower concept.
- Comes in a pack of 30, which covers most game prizes and table favours.
- Lightweight and easy to transport.
- Works well as stocking stuffers or goody bag additions.
Cons
The honey scent is pleasant but fairly subtle, which suits most guests. If your guests expect a strong, fragrant balm, this one might feel a bit plain.
Also, if your shower theme isn’t bear-related, these won’t fit as naturally.
Who This Is Best For
Hosts planning a bear-themed baby shower who want a practical, pocketable prize that guests will actually reach for again after the party.
Product 2: Brown Bear Pacifier Hunt Baby Shower Game Set (51PCS)
This one solves two problems at once. It’s a ready-to-run game and a favour set in a single purchase. The acrylic pacifiers are a touch we didn’t expect to love as much as we do.
Pros
The pacifier hunt is one of those games that gets even the quietest guests involved. You hide the tiny acrylic pacifiers around the party space before guests arrive, and whoever finds the most wins. Simple concept, but it genuinely creates movement and laughter.
We ran this game at a shower for a first-time mum, and it was the highlight of the afternoon. Even the grandparents were hunting behind chair cushions. The acrylic pacifiers feel solid in hand, not flimsy. They have a slight weight to them that makes them feel like a proper keepsake rather than a disposable prop.
The set includes a wooden hunt sign that stands on its own, which removes one more thing from your to-do list.
- 51-piece set covers a generous group.
- Acrylic pacifiers are reusable and well-finished.
- Brown bear theme is warm and popular right now.
Cons
The wooden hunt sign is compact, so consider where it will be most visible at your party. We propped ours against a vase, which worked fine, but it’s worth thinking through in advance.
Also, coordinating who found the most pacifiers can get competitive fast. Have a tiebreaker ready.
Who This Is Best For
Hosts who want a game that creates real energy at the party, not just something played while sitting down. This one gets people moving.
Product 3: Ctosree 50 Woodland Baby Shower Favors – Seed Packets
The most thoughtful out of the three. These seed packet favours carry a message that lasts well beyond the party, and the presentation is genuinely lovely.
Pros
Each set includes a decorative seed-style bag (without seeds), a flowerpot tag, a thank you card, and an organza bag. Everything comes packaged together, so your assembly time is minimal.
We’ve noticed something when we give presentation-focused favours like these. Guests treat them differently. They don’t toss them in a drawer. The combination of the organza bag, the tag, and the little flowerpot makes each set feel like a considered gift rather than an afterthought. Several guests kept theirs on a windowsill or shelf well after the party.
The complete set gives guests a beautiful keepsake that ties naturally into the theme of new life and growth.
- 50-piece set is generous for larger gatherings.
- Zero assembly stress. Everything is included.
- The woodland aesthetic suits both gender-neutral showers and nature-themed nurseries.
Cons
These are not a traditional prize in the competitive sense. They work best as a parting gift for all guests rather than a reward for a single game winner. If your games need a clear winner prize, pair these with something a little more exciting.
Who This Is Best For
Hosts who want a favour with emotional depth. This one is for the guest who will display it on their kitchen shelf long after the party is over.
Our Final Recommendation from Australian Favors
If you want to pick just one for game prizes specifically, go with the Pacifier Hunt Set. It earns its keep twice over, as the game itself and as the prize. Guests leave with something to remember.
If your guest list skews practical and your theme is bear-related, the lip balms are a reliable and well-priced choice that won’t let you down.
If you want something that genuinely moves people, the seed packets are quietly special. They’re not the flashiest, but they’re the ones guests talk about.
After helping hundreds of Australian families, we’ve learned this: the best baby shower gifts for games are the ones guests reach for again on a Tuesday morning, weeks after the confetti is gone.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a good baby shower gift for game winners?
The best baby shower gifts for games are practical, personal, and easy to transport. Guests shouldn’t need a bag to carry them out. Lip balms, small keepsakes, and seed packets are all good examples.
How many game prizes do I need for a baby shower?
A safe rule is to have at least one prize per planned game, plus a few extras. Most showers run 3 to 5 games, so a 30-pack or 50-pack set covers you comfortably with some left over for table décor or extra guests.
