A second baby shower is coming up, and it can be hard to choose a gift. The family already has the basics like a bassinet, nappy bag, and baby monitor. So what do you bring for baby number two?
Australian Favors have spent years testing and recommending baby shower gifts for real families. We know what gets used every day, what gets ignored, and what truly helps tired parents.
These three picks are our current top recommendations for baby shower gifts for second baby. We have tested each one ourselves, and we share both the pros and the downsides.
Quick Comparison: All 3 Products at a Glance
Product | Best For | Price Range (USD) | Our Rating |
Unordinary Toddler Big Brother & Little Sister Matching Outfits | Sentimental sibling gifting | $18 – $28 | 4/5 |
Baby Trend Sit N’ Stand Ultra Tandem Stroller | Practical two-child transport | $130 – $180 | 4/5 |
Tiny Ideas Me & My Brother Picture Frame | Keepsake and nursery décor | $12 – $18 | 4.5/5 |
Prices listed in USD. See the note at the bottom for Australian shipping and currency details.
1. Unordinary Toddler Big Brother & Little Sister Matching Outfits, Sibling Pant Set (Charcoal Black/Mauve)
One of the most loved baby shower gifts for the second child we’ve given. Parents usually react straight away and reach for their phone. The set includes a charcoal outfit for the older child and a mauve set for the newborn. Together, they look genuinely adorable on the first day home from the hospital.
Why We Love It
The newborn mauve piece is 100% cotton, which is gentle on delicate skin. The older sibling’s charcoal outfit is a cotton blend, which still feels soft and holds up well through regular washing.
The print is clean and stays intact after regular washing. Sizing is accurate, so no guesswork.
It also includes the older sibling, which matters. It helps them feel part of the moment.
What We Didn’t Like
Sizing between two sibling ages can be tricky to get right at purchase, and this particular set only works for a brother-sister pairing, not two boys or two girls.
Who This Is Best For
Families with a baby girl and an older brother. A simple, thoughtful gift that feels personal without custom work. Also a great pick if you want an affordable baby shower gift that feels personal without needing customisation.
The price is around $18 – $28 USD. See full features & reviews.
2. Baby Trend Sit N’ Stand Ultra Tandem Stroller, Phantom, Double Stroller for Newborn & Toddler
A second baby often makes a single stroller impractical. This is one of the most useful baby shower gifts for second baby because it solves that problem straight away.
Why We Love It
The rear platform lets the older child sit, stand, or walk when they want. It gives them freedom and avoids squeezing them into a tight seat.
It works with an infant car seat in both positions, so parents can use it from day one. It works with an infant car seat in both the front and rear positions, so parents can use it from day one. The older child uses the rear seat or the standing platform.
The front harness feels secure, and the dual foot-activated parking brakes are easy to use. The adjustable canopy helps keep a newborn shaded during walks.
Many parents find assembly fairly straightforward, often taking around 10–15 minutes with no tools required, though some find the included instructions unclear. The canopy rotates, which makes a real difference when the sun shifts mid-walk, and you’re trying to shade a sleeping newborn.
As a group gift idea for baby shower, this is an excellent option. Five or six friends chipping in can cover it comfortably, and it’s the kind of high-use, high-visibility gift a family will reference for years.
What We Didn’t Like
Steering requires some adjustment on uneven surfaces, the storage basket is large but awkward to access when fully loaded, and wheels need to be correctly aligned for the stroller to fold cleanly every time.
Who This Is Best For
Families with an older toddler who wants more independence. A strong choice for daily outings with two kids. Also ideal as a second baby shower gift registry recommendation for parents who haven’t yet worked out how they’ll manage two kids on school runs and park trips.
As this is a US product, Australian buyers should confirm it meets local safety standards before purchasing.
The price is around $130 – $180 USD. See full features & reviews.
3. Tiny Ideas Me & My Brother Picture Frame: Sibling Keepsake, Nursery Décor, Gray 4×6
This is a gift that families actually display. It sits on a shelf, bedside table, or in the nursery. It’s one of the most meaningful baby shower gifts here, and it’s budget-friendly.
Why We Love It
The white frame with a soft grey mat suits most nursery styles. The front reads “me & my brother” in a clean, modern print that sits well with virtually any nursery style. It holds a standard 4×6 photo, so printing is easy.
It is made from plastic and glass and, despite the modest price, feels solid and well-made. The mat is acid-free and helps prevent photo fading. It includes an easel stand for a tabletop display.
What we find most meaningful about this gift is what it quietly asks the parents to do. Take that first photo of the two siblings together and put it somewhere they’ll see every single day. That moment when the big brother meets the baby for the first time is a family’s treasure for life. This frame makes the act of commemorating it feel deliberate.
We’ve given this dozens of times, often as a secondary gift alongside something more practical. It works beautifully as a personalised baby shower gift when paired with a custom photo print already slipped inside. It also works perfectly on its own as a thoughtful standalone pick.
What We Didn’t Like
Only available in “me & my brother”. For two sisters, you’d need the separate sister version, and there’s no customisation option available.
Who This Is Best For
Anyone who wants a unique baby shower gift that doesn’t cost much but genuinely matters. A perfect pick if you’re attending a second or third baby shower and want something that feels different from the usual.
The price is around $12 – $18 USD. See full features & reviews.
Our Final Buying Advice From the Australian Favors Team
If you’re buying on your own and want to keep costs low, the Tiny Ideas sibling frame is our top pick. It looks great in photos and will stay on display for years. It’s a safe choice.
If you’re buying as a group and want something practical, choose the Baby Trend Sit N’ Stand. It solves a real daily need. Parents will use it from the first outing with two kids.
If the older child is a boy and the new baby is a girl, the matching sibling outfit set works well. It includes both children and makes those first photos more special.
Whatever you pick, a thoughtful gift matters. Second, babies deserve the same care and attention.
— The Australian Favors Team
Please note: These products are sourced from US-based sellers on Amazon, and prices are listed in USD. They can be shipped to Australia, but we recommend checking availability, delivery times, shipping costs, and the current AUD equivalent before ordering.
